A brass balance scale on a car showroom counter. One pan is heaped with blank paper slips. The other holds a single glowing telephone handset and hangs lower.

Call analysis

BDC representative scorecard: rate calls, not call counts

A BDC representative scorecard should rate what each rep says on calls, not how many calls they made. See what to put on it, with example lines.

Krunal Ambaliya

5 min read

Share

Say your busiest rep made the most calls last month, yet your quietest rep booked more visits. A BDC representative scorecard should explain that gap, so rate each rep on what they say on calls, not on call counts. (A BDC, or business development center, is the team that answers sales calls and books appointments.)

A scorecard that only counts calls teaches your reps to make more calls, not better ones.

Key takeaways

  • A BDC representative scorecard should rate each rep on what they say on calls, not on how many calls they made.
  • Call counts show how busy a rep was. They do not show what the customer heard.
  • Start with three lines: did the rep ask for the visit, give a straight answer, and listen.
  • No card settles how to rate a rep who takes the hardest calls. Comparing reps on the same kind of call helps, but the judgment stays with a person.

What is a BDC representative scorecard?

A BDC representative scorecard is a short record of how one rep is doing. A manager can fill it in each week or month and use it in one-on-one talks.

The easy way to build one is from numbers you track already: calls made, appointments booked, time on the phone. Those numbers are simple to pull.

They say how busy a rep was. They do not say what the customer heard.

That gap can cost the dealership in two ways. A rep can hit every number while customers hang up without a visit. And a strong rep who takes the hard calls can look weak on paper.

Scorecard line What it tells you What it leaves out
Calls made How busy the rep was What was said on any call
Appointments booked The result Which calls were lost, and why
Time on the phone How long calls ran Whether the time helped the customer
What was said on each call Where the rep is strong or weak What happened after the call

What should a BDC representative scorecard measure?

Measure things the rep controls and you can hear on the call. Three lines are enough to start. The example calls below are made up for illustration.

Did the rep ask for the visit?

  • Customer: "Okay, let me think about it."
  • Rep: "No problem. Have a great day."

The customer was still on the line, and nobody offered a time. If this pair shows up often for one rep, price may not be the problem. The calls are ending without an ask.

Did the rep give a straight answer?

  • Customer: "What would I pay in total, with all the fees?"
  • Rep: "You would have to come in for that."

The customer asked a fair question and got a brush-off. Listen for whether the rep answers, or says when someone will call back with the answer.

Did the rep listen?

  • Customer: "Like I told the last person, I need three rows of seats."
  • Rep: "So what kind of vehicle are you looking for?"

The customer had to say it twice. That can mean the rep is following a script, not the call.

Our post on scoring every inbound BDC call lists five checks to run on every call. This post is about the card for each rep.

How do you fill in a BDC rep scorecard by hand?

Pick the same kind of call for every rep, such as first-time sales calls. Read or listen to a handful for each rep.

Mark each line yes or no, and write down the exact words behind every no. A mark might read: asked for the visit, no, "Have a great day."

Then test the scorecard itself. The US Office of Personnel Management says performance standards should be "measurable, understandable, verifiable, equitable, and achievable."

That guidance is written for federal agencies, not dealerships. Those words still work as a test for each line on the card.

Can you hear it on the call? Would the rep agree it is fair? Can the rep do it on the next call?

By hand, you will only cover a few calls per rep. That is the weak point: a rep's card can turn on which calls you happened to pick.

How Metricsense does this

  1. You cannot listen to every call your BDC took this week. Metricsense reads every call, not a sample. What you know about each rep then comes from all of their calls, not the few you picked.
  2. Your managers each judge a call a little differently. Your team describes how it judges a call, in plain words. Metricsense turns that into a check. Your team compares the results with its own judgment until the two match.
  3. A rep disputes a mark, and nobody remembers the call. Every flag links to the exact moment in the call behind it. You and the rep read the same words.
  4. You do not know which rep needs help with what. Both sides of every call are scored: what the customer asked for, and how the rep handled it. A Call Quality Index for each rep shows where one person is weaker than their peers, so coaching goes there.

Here is the kind of thing you get back.

Illustrative data, not actual customer data

  • Customer: "Can you just tell me if the price online is the real price?"
  • Rep: "Prices change a lot. Best thing is to stop by."
  • Check it was flagged against: the rep gives a straight answer to a price question, or says when someone will call back with one.
  • What you learn from this: the rep moved to the visit before answering. If the same flag keeps coming up for this rep, coach that moment.

You can read more on the page about call transcript analysis.

What stays with a person?

A flag is a possible issue with the evidence attached. A person decides what it is. Nothing is acted on automatically.

So the manager still does the part that matters: the talk with the rep. Australia's Fair Work Ombudsman, in its guide to managing underperformance, advises managers to describe the problem clearly and point to specific examples.

A scorecard built from calls gives you those examples. It does not have the conversation for you.

Tell your reps what is on the card before you use it. The same guide lists unclear standards as a common reason people perform poorly. A rep who knows the three lines can work on them.

What can a scorecard built from calls not show?

It cannot tell you how to rate a rep who takes the hardest calls. Comparing reps on the same kind of call helps. It does not remove the judgment, and we have no rule that does.

Metricsense works from your call recordings or their written text (transcripts). If your phone system keeps audio only, the calls are turned into text first, then read.

The card also cannot tell you who showed up. Keep each rep's booked appointments on the same card.

How do you try this on your own calls?

Write your three lines down the way your managers would say them. A free pilot reads around 50 of your calls against them and gives you a readout inside a week.

Book a free pilot on your calls

Share this article

Back to the blog